One step forwards and a stumble backwards seems to be the name of the game with this restoration. You may recall that I had inverted the engine to gain access to the internals and the 'next step' was to disconnect the conrods from the crankshaft with the theory of being able to push one piston at a time out of the cylinder bores.
Well, that is where this update starts... Removing the nuts from the end of the piston conrods was nowhere as easy as I was expecting. Firstly the nuts have antique split pins, these pins have two 'legs' that are pushed through the nut and bolt and then bent in opposite directions which prevents the nuts from coming undone. This is a tried and tested design concept and is perfectly reasonable until you want to remove them because straightening those legs to push the pin out of the hole is usually a bit of a pain because once the pin is distorted it is usually reluctant to slide out the hole designed for a straight pin.
These pins definitely fitted into that category AND they were in a confined space so access was limited and very fiddly. There were also a couple of cases where the split pins were too long and could not be pushed out of the bolts because they hit the crankshaft. cutting the pins shorter was not possible because the access was too limited. These little rascals took the most time to tease out but eventually I got there.
I could now undo the nuts that had been secured by the split pins - or so I thought... the nuts seemed to be rather tighter than I would expect them to be. Make that VERY much tighter than I would expect. I could not move any of them with a normal socket wrench which you would normally expect to be able to do if they were tightened to the factory torque setting of 30ft-lb. So I pulled out the trusty torque wrench and kept winding up the torque setting until the nuts DID move. Shock-Horror - there wasn't a single nut that was under 100ft-lb and one of them was closer to 125ft-lb. I certainly wont be reusing THOSE bolts!
Sadly - I was not able to remove all of the nuts which means that I still cant remove the crankshaft to persuade the pistons out. The rotation of the crankshaft means that the two pistons which are halfway through their rotational stroke are very close to the side of the engine block - which means there isn't room to get a socket onto the nuts - which means I cant fit the (wound up) torque wrench onto the sockets. This caused some minor irritation on my part along with a bit of muttering as it had taken rather a long time to get to this point...
So... back to trying to remove rust from the cylinder bores so that perhaps I could release one or two of the un-bolted pistons and maybe then partially turn the crankshaft to gain access to those tricky nuts.
I had read on the internet about a rust removal liquid that is not caustic, is reusable and is safe to flush into domestic drains so I thought I would give it a go. The internet had demonstrated submerging an entire chassis in this liquid so that rust was removed inside and outside of the chassis rails. Worth a try I thought.
This liquid is called 'Evaporust' and having tried it on other rusty components - I was quite impressed and I can add my recommendation to using it. It leaves a pretty clean surface that needs to be washed and then treated with a rust preventative to stop it returning but it DOES do what it says on the tin. In the picture above you can see the cylinder bores filled with this liquid and I left it for a week to work its magic. After 7 days I removed the now-black liquid and poured it into a spare container for re-use. The cylinder bores looked substantially better now so I treated the top of each piston to a taste of my air-powered hammer. I wasn't expecting much to happen and I can advise that my expectations were met - it had made no difference at all.
I cant tell you how disappointed I was feeling at this moment - perhaps the engine CANT be un-seized and given the rarity of these engines, that would almost certainly mean that the car would be way beyond economical repair. It was a sad time.
Rather despondently, I decided to reach out to Davenport Jaguars - a company who specialised in the sale and restoration of pre-war and early post war Jaguars. I have bought some parts from them before so I knew they had a pretty substantial workshop (and buildings full of spare parts) and I was aware that they used a particular chap to do all of their engine work. Problem is Mr Davenport who owned and managed the company was aged and has sadly passed away. The company is now managed by his son but it's not his day job, so I reached out to the new owner asking to talk to their engine builder.
I have now spoken to said engine expert 'Geoff' and we had a very productive conversation about restoring my 3.5ltr engine and in restoring MK4's in general. To cut a long story short, he was less concerned about the seized engine than he was about cracks between the water ways and other areas of the engine, he mentioned if there were any cracks between the water ways and the push rod enclosures - the engine is scrap...
I have been trying to un-seize the engine for around 18 months so to hear that this was not the worst potential problem was rather hard to hear...
Luckily the engine is mostly stripped apart so I carefully cleaned up and looked at the voiced problem areas. Cutting to the chase - I am not able to 'see' any cracks anywhere so I am hopeful that I have a good block. Geoff's experienced eye will be the final word though so we spoke about engine rebuild costs and the next steps.
Right now I am putting the engine back together (loosely) and will then book the engine in for evaluation and hopefully a full rebuild. Geoff did warn me that he is just one man and is very busy with other work, but having rebuilt 96 of these engines he is confident we as long as the block is not cracked, then we can get to a good reliable running engine... that was great news to my ears especially as I was in the zone of thinking the engine was NOT rebuildable.
Oh, you may be wondering how Geoff plans to unseize the engine...
He said 'there are a number of things he will try but worst case he will simply put the block into a jig and grind the top of the pistons off the conrods, basically grinding away the part of the pistons that are stuck to the cylinder bores'. That is a tool that not many people have access to and will of course destroy the pistons but they would be replaced anyway... more on this at a later date once Geoff has the engine in his hands...
This is the stuff I now use to de-rust metal parts:





















